Quick Summary: We have picked the Nordic Ware Microwave Tortilla Warmer as the top tortilla warmer as it is large, very versatile, and creates a very tight seal to keep your food warm and fresh. It looks nice enough that you can leave it on the counter for part of your décor. It is also microwave safe, dishwasher safe, and very budget friendly.
With lots of different models on the market, choosing the perfect tortilla warmer can be quite a feat. They range in size, price, and construction, at the minimum.
Some are microwave and oven safe while others can only be used in the microwave. The factors of each can be confusing, but with some knowledge, you can confidently choose the best one for you.
Quick Navigation
- 10 Best Tortilla Warmers Comparison
- Reviews of Top 10 Tortilla Warmers
- How to Choose the Right Tortilla Warmer
- Why a Tortilla Warmer
- Our Recommendation
10 Best Tortilla Warmers Comparison
 | 1. Nordic Ware Microwave Tortilla Warmer (Best Overall)The Nordic Ware microwave-safe tortilla warmer is a 10-inch option that is made in the U.S. and is BPA-free and contains no melamine. | Read Our Review |
 | 2. IMUSA USA Mexi-1008W Cloth Tortilla Warmer (Best Budget)The Imusa Multi-colored cloth tortilla warmer is a 10-inch option that is microwave-safe and can keep your tortillas warm for up to an hour. | Read Our Review |
 | 3. KooK Ceramic Tortilla WarmerThe ceramic Kook tortilla warmer is a durable option that comes with many different colors and holds up to 23 tortillas at one time. | Read Our Review |
 | 4. RSVP International Stoneware Tortilla WarmerThe RSVP International Maiz-R is a tortilla warmer made from stoneware and holds tortillas up to eight inches in diameter and 20 at a time. | Read Our Review |
 | 5. KooK Quality Plastic Tortilla WarmerThe Kook tortilla warmer is a high-quality plastic option that can hold up to 12 tortillas at a time that is up to eight inches in size. | Read Our Review |
 | 6. Now Designs Terracotta Tortilla WarmerThe Now Designs terracotta tortilla warmer is handcrafted and comes with a lid that is easy to lift and is oven safe in temperatures up to 400 degrees. | Read Our Review |
 | 7. Maples Handmade Pine Needle Tortilla WarmerThe Maples Handmade pine needle tortilla warmer is a unique and organic option that has a 100% cotton tortilla sleeve and can keep tortillas warm for a long time. | Read Our Review |
 | 8. Dexas Extra Large Microwavable WarmerThe Dexas tortilla warmer is an extra-large option that is made from a granite design and can be used in the microwave and has a cool-touch handle. | Read Our Review |
 | 9. La Tortilla Oven Tortilla Warmer Fabric PouchThe La Tortilla Oven are two-sided tortilla warmers that can handle up to 12-inch tortillas corn and flour and are insulated and microwave-safe. | Read Our Review |
 | 10. Simpluxx Microwaveable X-Large Tortilla 2 Pack PouchThe Simpluxx two-pack of tortilla warmers that are extra-large and can fit 12-inch tortillas inside each warmer and can handle up to 15 tortillas at a time. | Read Our Review |
Reviews of Top 10 Tortilla Warmers
To find the best, we checked out dozens of models and the ratings and reviews of them all. After careful consideration, we chose the following ten tortilla warmers due to their construction, price, size, and versatility.
Best Overall
1. Nordic Ware Microwave Tortilla Warmer
What You Will Love: It has a tight seal and versatile uses.
The Nordic Tortilla Warmer is a great kitchen tool for those that love tacos and burritos, or even things like pancakes.
Its large 10-inch size makes it large enough to hold many foods you cook. Thanks to the tight seal, this warmer can be used to keep your pancakes and waffles warmed, or it can be placed in the microwave to heat up tortillas.
It is BPA and melamine safe, and it is dishwasher safe on the top rack. As with most new plastic items, you may notice a smell through the first few uses. Also, buyers say that it takes a lot of storage space.
However, because it is also a nice looking item, some users have started leaving it on their counter in between uses. As it typically runs under $15, it is an excellent deal.
Pros:
- 10″ big enough for burritos,
- Oven safe,
- Versatile uses,
- Bpa and melamine free,
- Tight seal,
- Top rack dishwasher proof,
- Great price
Cons:
- May leave plastic smell on food for a while,
- Takes up a lot of storage space
Best Budget Tortilla Warmer
2. IMUSA USA Mexi-1008W Cloth Tortilla Warmer
What You Will Love: It has a fun and festive look that can hang on the wall between uses.
The IMUSA USA Mexi-1008W Cloth is both bright and colorful and can keep your tortillas or other flat bread warm for up to one hour. The 10-inch size fits large breads but does not take up much storage space. It is very easy to use and microwave safe.
As it is lined with plastic on the inside, it can wear out over time. However, you can extend its usage by taking proper care of it. Although it is machine washable, a washing machine might wear it out quicker. Instead, turn it inside out and wipe it out with a damp cloth. At less than $20, it is a great choice.
Pros:
- Festive and multicolored,
- Hangs like a pot holder in between uses,
- Large, oven safe,
- Easy to use,
- Keeps tortillas warm up to an hour,
- Machine washable,
- Versatile
Cons:
- Plastic lining can wear out
Best Ceramic Tortilla Warmer
3. KooK Ceramic Tortilla Warmer
What You Will Love: This tortilla warmer is bright, colorful, and hand painted into a design that is a work of art. KooK Ceramic Tortilla Warmer.
The KooK Ceramic Tortilla Warmer is very fun and colorful. It is fully insulated to keep tortillas and other flat bread warm for up to an hour.
It is both microwave and top rack dishwasher safe. As it only holds tortillas up to 8 inches, those who love larger tacos and burritos should probably choose a different warmer. Also, as it is ceramic, dropping or mishandling it can cause it to break easily. At less than $25, the price is great for the product.
Pros:
- Insulated,
- Keeps warm up to one hour,
- Colorful hand painted design,
- Oven safe,
- Easy to clean,
- Top rack dishwasher proof,
- Nice price
Cons:
- Can break or chip easily, only 8 inch
Best Stoneware Tortilla Warmer
4. RSVP International Stoneware Tortilla Sever & Warmer
What You Will Love: This tortilla warmer is oven safe as well as dishwasher and microwave safe.
The RSVP International Stoneware Tortilla Warmer is a lead free tortilla warmer with a red glaze.
Unlike most other tortilla warmers, this one is over safe up to 325 degrees. Sadly, it only holds 8 inch tortillas and is reported to be rather shallow.
Therefore, it does not fit many tortillas in, though it would probably be a good size for a couple. At over $30, it is a higher priced warmer on this list, but for the ability to put it in the oven, it might be worth that and a little more.
Pros:
- Microwave safe,
- Oven safe up to 325 degrees,
- Dishwasher proof,
- Lead free,
- Festive red design
Cons:
- A little higher price than other options,
- Only 8 inch,
- A little shallow
Best Plastic Tortilla Warmer
5. KooK Quality Plastic Tortilla Warmer
What You Will Love: It keeps up to 12 tortillas warm for up to one hour.
The KooK Quality Plastic Tortilla Warmer is a well insulated warmer. Though it only holds 8 inch tortillas, it is not shallow like the previous option.
At 2.5 inches high, it holds up to 12 tortillas. It is both oven safe and FDA safe. It is also top rack dishwasher safe. If you buy more than one, they are stackable meaning that they will not take up too much space.
You can choose from a crimson red or what I would call guacamole green tortilla warmer. At under $15, it is a great price.
Pros:
- Deep, holds up to 12 tortillas,
- Great price,
- Well insulated,
- Microwave safe and dishwasher proof,
- Stackable if you buy more than one,
- Fda approved
Cons:
- Only 8 inches
Best Terracotta Tortilla Warmer
6. Now Designs Terracotta Tortilla Warmer
What You Will Love: It is very attractive and is deeper than many other warmers.
The Now Designs Terracotta Tortilla Warmer comes in a beautiful navy blue color or white. It is glazed and high-fired terracotta, making it very durable. It is both microwave safe and oven safe up to 400 degrees.
As it is only 8.75 inches wide, it will not hold 12″ tortillas. However, as it is 3.5 inches deep, it will hold quite a few 8 inch tortillas. Unfortunately, it is hand wash only. At around $25, it is not the cheapest option but also not the most expensive one on the list.
Pros:
- Oven safe,
- Oven safe up to 400 degrees,
- Easy to lift handle,
- 3.5 inches tall,
- Comes in pretty navy blue or white
Cons:
- Hand wash only,
- Only 8.75 inches wide
Best Handmade Tortilla Warmer
7. Maples Handmade Pine Needle Tortilla Warmer
What You Will Love: It is 100% hand made and has a cute traditional look.
The Maples Handmade Pine Needle is different than all the others on our list due to its unique look. It is handmade with pine needles woven together, making it cute yet a somewhat odd choice for a tortilla warmer.
Some buyers complain that it smells of pine and, therefore, makes the food smells like pine. This may not bother everyone. It comes with a nickel rimmed top and a 100% cotton tortilla sleeve.
As it is close to $35, it is one of the highest options on the list. Since baskets have a tendency to fall apart, be gentle with this warmer to keep it around longer.
Pros:
- 100% handmade,
- Nickel rim top,
- 100% cotton tortilla sleeve,
- Cute traditional look
Cons:
- Smells like, shallow,
- A little high price,
- Should be gentle with it
Best Large Tortilla Warmer
8. Dexas Extra Large Microwavable Warmer
What You Will Love: It is very durable and very well insulated.
The Dexas Extra Large Microwavable Tortilla Warmer is a uniquely designed that comes in three attractive color options. You can pick between granite, black and red. It has a polyurethane construction and a cool touch silicone handle.
It is both dishwasher and microwave safe. As it is well insulated, it will keep your tortillas warm for some time. It is only 9.5 inches wide so it will not fit 12″ tortillas. However, it is 3 inches deep so it will hold a nice stack of 8 inch ones. At under $18, it is a great deal.
Pros:
- Three color options,
- Microwavable,
- Great insulation,
- Poly construction,
- Great price,
- Cool touch silicone handle,
- Stackable, cute design,
- Dishwasher proof
Cons:
- Will not fit 12″ tortillas
9. La Tortilla Oven Tortilla Warmer Fabric Pouch
What You Will Love: The La Tortilla Oven fabric pouch tortilla warmers are a large option that can be used in the microwave and are insulated for keeping warm for up to an hour. The designs on the pouch are Mexican inspired and work perfectly for authentic dishes with homemade tortillas.
12-inch Warmers
These large size tortilla warmers allow you to fill each pouch with up to fifteen tortillas that are about 12 inches in size. This enables you to keep up to 30 tortillas between the two pouches that come in this pack.
Double-Sided Design
These warmer pouches have two different designs on either side of the pouch that will match any party. Just pick which design you like the most and flip the warmer over so that side is visible and you can match the design to color to your decorations.
Food-Safe
These American-made items are Mexican-inspired with a unique design that celebrates the Hispanic culture. The pouches are made out of BPA-free material that is food safe.
Pros:
- Large option
- Two-pack for price
- Designs on both sides
- Food-safe
- BFA-free
Cons:
- Material stains easily
- Color in the interior tends to transfer
10. Simpluxx Microwaveable X-Large Tortilla 2 Pack Pouch
What You Will Love: The Simpluxx tortilla warmer pouches come in a two-pack that comes with two various designs on each pouch. Each design has a fun and Mexican-inspired design that can be a great addition to any party décor.
Thick Fabric
These fabric pouches are great tortilla warmers and are made from thick fabric that keeps the tortillas warm for a longer amount of time. The extra padding also makes a nice design that makes it perfect to leave out for guests.
Two-Pack of Warmers
This choice comes with two separate warmers that can both be used at the same time. Each warmer holds up to 15 tortillas each, for a total of 30 between the entire pack. Each is 12 inches wide and can accommodate large tortillas.
Microwavable
Both of these tortilla warmers pouches are safe to use in the microwave so you can heat up the tortillas together or heat them up on the stove and put them in the pouches to maintain the heat with a bit of crispiness.
Pros:
- Two-pack option
- Fun designs on both pouches
- Thick fabric build
- Various designs
- Microwave-safe
Cons:
- Do not leave in microwavable for a long time
- Does not close completely and lets out air
How to Choose the Right Tortilla Warmer?
When you decide to buy a tortilla warmer, consider these factors before choosing:
Size
This is important as it revolves around the size of tortilla you like to eat. If you are good with 8 inch tortillas, you have more options as this is the most popular.
However, you can find those that hold much larger tortillas. Also, the height affects how many tortillas it can hold at a time. If there are only one or two people eating, a shallow one is probably fine. Larger families will need a deeper warmer.
Warming Ability
There is no reason to buy a tortilla warmer if it does not do its main job, which is keeping the tortillas warm. You might find some that keep them warm for around 30 minutes, but some go all the way up to an hour.
Constituents
There are different materials used in the warmers including plastic, stone, pine, and more. If you choose plastic, be sure that it is BPA free.
Ease of Usage
You do not want a complicated contraption. A tortilla warmer should be very easy to use. If it requires a long list of steps, it is probably not a good option.
Price
While prices differ, most of the prices are within $15 or $20 of one another. In other words, there is no reason to choose bad quality for a cheaper price, as they are going to stay in a similar price range.
Why a Tortilla Warmer?
Every soft shell taco lover knows the struggle: keeping those delicious tortillas warm throughout the meal. It seems no matter how hard you try, they just do not want to stay warm. With a tortilla warmer, that is not a problem.
Though these warmers are made from different materials, the majority of them are insulated well enough to keep those tortillas warm for up to an hour. That is plenty of time to stuff your belly.
Additionally, they are microwave safe, so you can put them in the warmer straight from the package and heat them up. Then, simply set the warmer on the table, and voila! Warm and fresh tortillas.
With all of the ones available, it is not difficult to find one that matches your kitchen decor. You can also find those that are oven safe if you prefer to heat your tortillas up that way.
Our Recommendation: Best Tortilla Warmers
Tortilla warmers can be very handy dinnerware, especially for anyone who loves soft shell tacos. It is the perfect addition to any taco night or other Mexican dinner that you would like to have. It adds a great way to hold beans and rice and gives you another side dish for your dinner guests.
There are various options of tortilla warmers that you have to sort through when you are shopping on your own that could be overwhelming. All brands claim to have the best option, which makes it hard to choose.
Well, with our list of favorites to look at, you can choose to go with our top pick of the Nordic Ware Microwave Tortilla Warmer. However, if you would like something that is a little different, take another look at the other choices to see which one will be the best tortilla warmer for your kitchen.
Then, next time you have dinner guests, they will be able to have fresh and warm tortillas with their meal to create the perfect cherry on top of a great night.
More Related Articles:
- Top Meal Prep Containers
- Best Tupperware For Meal Prep
- Top Insulated Lunch Boxes
- Top Airtight Containers
